Faced with the choice between changing one’s mind and proving that there is no need to do so, almost everybody gets busy on the proof.
-John Kenneth Galbraith.
“Faced with the choice between changing one’s mind…”
- This sets up the core dilemma. It acknowledges that we are constantly presented with information and experiences that could potentially challenge our existing beliefs.
- “Changing one’s mind” represents a process of cognitive dissonance – the discomfort we feel when our beliefs and reality clash.
“…and proving that there is no need to do so…”
- This highlights the alternative path: defending our existing beliefs, even if they are flawed.
- “Proving that there is no need to do so” involves actively seeking out evidence that confirms our beliefs, dismissing contradictory evidence, and constructing justifications for our positions.
“…almost everybody gets busy on the proof.”
- This emphasizes the universality of this tendency. It suggests that most people, regardless of their intelligence or education, are susceptible to this cognitive bias.
- “Gets busy on the proof” implies a deliberate and active effort to defend our beliefs. This can involve:
- Selective perception: Paying attention to information that confirms our beliefs and ignoring information that contradicts them.
- Confirmation bias: Seeking out sources that reinforce our existing views.
- Rationalization: Creating logical-sounding explanations for our beliefs, even if they are based on faulty reasoning.
- Denial: Refusing to acknowledge evidence that contradicts our beliefs.
- Attacking the source of the contradictory information.
Why This Happens:
- Cognitive dissonance: Changing our minds can be uncomfortable and emotionally challenging. It requires us to admit that we were wrong, which can be damaging to our self-esteem.
- Ego protection: Our beliefs are often tied to our sense of identity. Changing them can feel like a personal attack.
- Social pressure: We may fear being judged or ostracized by others if we change our minds.
- Sunk cost fallacy: We may have invested a lot of time and effort into our beliefs, making it difficult to let them go.
- Emotional attachment: Many beliefs are tied to our emotions, therefore changing a belief can cause emotional distress.
Implications:
- Obstacles to progress: This tendency can hinder our ability to learn, grow, and adapt to changing circumstances.
- Political polarization: It can contribute to political gridlock and social division, as people become entrenched in their beliefs and unwilling to compromise.
- Personal relationships: it can cause conflict in relationships when people are unable to see another persons point of view.
- Scientific advancement: It can slow down scientific progress, as researchers cling to established theories even in the face of contradictory evidence.
Overcoming This Tendency:
- Cultivate intellectual humility: Recognize that we are all fallible and that our beliefs may be wrong.
- Practice critical thinking: Learn to evaluate information objectively and to identify cognitive biases.
- Embrace uncertainty: Be willing to accept that there are things we don’t know and that our beliefs may change over time.
- Seek out diverse perspectives: Expose yourself to different viewpoints and be willing to consider them.
- Be open to feedback: Listen to others’ opinions and be willing to consider their perspectives.
By recognizing this tendency and actively working to overcome it, we can become more open-minded, adaptable, and intellectually honest.
Do read the Disclaimer